1.(29) Kentwan Balmer, DT, North Carolina - Balmer will lineup as a 3-4 end most likely and attempt to fill the very large shoes created by the retirement of Bryant Young, who deserves more rounds of applause then anyone could imagine. It's not a sexy pick, and it's hardly revolutionary. However, it's a solid one. Look for Balmer to start soon.
Pick Grade: B+
2.(39) Chilo Rachal, G, USC - I wasn't crazy about this pick. However, it seems that everyone raved about how NFL-Ready Rachal seems to be than his counterparts. He played in a very pro style offense under Pete Carroll, so I don't doubt it. If he comes as advertised, he could solidify what should already be a good offensive line.
Pick Grade: B
3. (75) Reggie Smith, CB, Oklahoma - Oh, How I love this pick. It was great value for a guy who looked to be a first round talent, and he fills a need because he can either play cornerback or safety. Doesn't have tremendous speed, but good knowledge of the game and a nose for the ball more than makes up for it.
Pick Grade: A-
4. (107) Cody Wallace, C, Texas A&M - While I liked Steve Justice, who was still on the board, much better, you can't underestimate just what having a back-up swing player on the offensive line does. It allows the 49ers to backup both guards and center with a solid, smart, tough player. Solid Pick.
Pick Grade: B-
6.(174) Josh Morgan, WR, Virginia Tech - Well, this is interesting. VT hardly ever throws the ball, and when they did, it was typical to Eddie Royal. Therefore, Morgan is a bit of a tough player to evaluate. However, He also could be a diamond in the rough. The Niners must have liked something they saw.
Pick Grade: ? (Hey, We'll call it a C.)
7. (214) Larry Grant, OLB, Ohio State - Relatively productive player for Jim Tressel. Wonder about his ability to ever play anything more than special teams.
Pick Grade: D
Overall Grade: B
Not a whole lot of flash for Jason's team, but filled some holes nicely. Outside of Morgan, who is a TOTAL wild card, they will get the production they expect from most of these guys, but won't find themselves hitting any real home runs.
Showing posts with label 2008 NFL Draft Grades. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2008 NFL Draft Grades. Show all posts
5/19/08
AFC West Draft Grades - Kansas City Chiefs
| 1 | 5(5) | Glenn Dorsey | DT | LSU |
| I don't love Dorsey as much as other experts do. It's hard to argue against trends and lately we have seen a ton of high profile Defensive Tackles that are busts in the NFL (Johnathan Sullivan, Dewayne Robertson, Ryan Sims, Travis Johnson, Marcus Tubbs, Jimmy Kennedy, William Joseph, Wendell Bryant and to a lesser extent Allan Branch.) Now of course players have developed to become All-Pro's but the injury potential of guys with this type of body are worrisome, especially considering Dorsey has already had some injuries. With that all said, Dorsey is a complete player and a very good one at that. You can argue he was the best player in the draft and to get him at five could be considered a steal. I'm going to give this pick a high grade because it deserves it, however if Dorsey flames out remember you heard it here first. A | ||||
| 1 | 15(15) | Branden Albert | OG | VIRGINIA |
| Taking a page from the Bill Parcells play book the Chiefs are rebuilding in the trenches. I like Albert more than Anthony does. Albert was one of the real late risers in this draft. It seemed that all of a sudden everyone realized "hey he could play Left Tackle!" and while in my opinion the jury is still out at worst Albert should be a very good interior lineman. The Chiefs have a ton of holes on the offensive line and to get someone of Alberts versatility is a coup. Now remember they acquired this pick by trading Jared Allen, without that trade they may have been stuck reaching for Albert, or another O-Lineman at 5. That trade allowed them to take Dorsey or whoever was the best available player at 5 and get the best Offensive lineman later. I liked the trade at the time for K.C. and I think it looks even better in hindsight. A- | ||||
| 2 | 4(35) | Brandon Flowers | CB | VIRGINIA TECH |
| Flowers is an interesting prospect. He has some character issues stemming from a picture posted of cash and what appears to be weed on his Facebook. He also doesn't have ideal height/bulk but he plays bigger than he is. He's better in zone than man to man and has good ball skills. Despite his small stature he plays the run very well and is physical. The only question I have is his fit in the Cover 2 because of his size. I think someone like Patrick Lee (drafted 25 spots later) might have been a better fit. B | ||||
| 3 | 10(73) | Jamaal Charles | RB | TEXAS |
Running back clearly wasn't a need for K.C. but it seems like they are preparing for life after L.J which might come sooner than people realize. Charles was my favorite of the second tier RB's and if he went higher I wouldn't have batted an eyelash. Charles has starting potential. The only knock on this pick here is it didn't adess a need. No one is going to be able to run behind such a porous O-Line. This pick is one that will probably look better in a year or two than it does now. B | ||||
| 3 | 13(76) | Brad Cottam | TE | TENNESSEE |
| Cottam was one of my favorite players in this years Draft. His rise was meteoric as he went from 6/7th round developmental type to a 3rd rounder. His blocking ability is well documented but it's his intriguing mix of size and speed that lead him to being drafted so highly. He has the size to potential be used as a tackle but he also has great speed (4.63) for a tight end (let alone of his size.) Cottam is another pick that will probably look better in a year or so than it does now. For now Cottams immediate role will be as a blocking tight end and that should immediately pay dividends. In the future If Cottam can put together all his skills this pick could end up looking like a steal. | ||||
| B | ||||
| 3 | 19(82) | DaJuan Morgan | S | NORTH CAROLINA ST |
| Another great pick but once again the for a saftey is questionable. Morgan has great physical tools but is raw and only started one year in college. He's a guy who is a coaches dream, the type that would run through a wall if you asked him to. He's a developmental type who will start out as a special teams guru. Again this pick could look alot better in 2-3 years than it does now. B+ | ||||
| 4 | 6(105) | William Franklin | WR | MISSOURI |
| Another intriguing player. Franklin (much like Cottam and Morgan) has never played up to his ability. He has intriguing physical tools but hasn't put it together yet. In the 4th round it's acceptable to roll the dice on this time of player but Frankin is no sure thing and with the Chiefs depth chart so think it would have made more sense to address this position earlier. B- | ||||
| 5 | 5(140) | Brandon Carr | CB | GRAND VALLEY ST |
| Classic Cover 2 type corner. Should provide needed depth. B- | ||||
| 6 | 4(170) | Barry Richardson | OT | CLEMSON |
| It shouldn't have taken this long for the Chiefs to address O-Line again in this draft. Richardson has a ton of talent and tools but as was the theme of a lot of picks in this draft he's an underachiver who's a boom or bust player. However, in the 6th round what else can you ask for. B+ | ||||
| 6 | 16(182) | Kevin Robinson | WR | UTAH STATE |
| Possession receiver who should carve out a role on special teams. | ||||
| 7 | 3(210) | Brian Johnston | DE | GARDNER WEBB |
| A guy Scott Wright was obsessed about. Ironically he compares him to Jared Allen. Once again in the 7th round you can't ask for much more. B+ | ||||
| 7 | 32(239) | Mike Merritt | TE | CENTRAL FLORIDA |
| Another blocking tight end. Don't know how he makes the team considering they drafted Cottam F | ||||
A great draft. Of course when you have so many draft picks it's easy to have a great draft. For a team that typically drafts poorly this draft was a welcome surprise. If you want to knock this draft you can argue that they took a lot of boom or bust types (Cottam, Morgan, Franklin, Richardson) however with so many picks it's alright to roll the dice a few times. Also they didn't reach for any of these players. You can also knock the draft for not addressing needs (O-Line and WR) with more urgency. Albert is a great start but he alone can't turn around the O-Line. Franklin has potential but he's starting across from DeWayne Bowe right now? With all that being said you can't argue that a team that needed a strong haul in a rebuilding year got just that. A- | ||||
5/16/08
NFL Draft Grades - NFC West - St. Louis Rams
1.(2) Chris Long, DE, Virginia - Long is an excellent pass rusher, even when he was coming out of the 3-4 end position in college. He's got a great motor, and is an excellent character guy. He's going to be a good player, and he's convinced me of that all year.
Pick Grade: A
2. (33) Donnie Avery, WR, Houston - Whoa. Az Hakim alert. This guy was the first receiver taken and really is nothing but a track star. He played in a system that really allowed him to showcase his talent, but that's not saying alot when your playing in conference USA. A HUGE REACH.
Pick Grade: F
3. (65) John Greco, OT, Toledo - I like players from the MAC. Greco is a nasty player who has all of the physical tools to do the job. The thing I like most is the attitude.
Pick Grade: B
4a. (101) Justin King, CB, Penn State - King is a fun case study. He's a big school guy, and he's fast as all hell. However, can he really cover? Let's see. He's probably play nickelback on the fast turf in the Ed Jones dome.
Pick Grade: C
4b. (128) Kennan Burton, WR, Kentucky - This is the developmental receiver pick. Burton is 6'1 and has good speed, but is raw. He was Andre Woodson's top guy at Kentucky, but needs some time to figure out the NFL game.
Pick Grade: C+
5. (157) Roy Schuening, G, Oregon St. - More nasty guards. I like the idea of taking guys who are tough over anything else, and Schuening played the entire year with Pneumonia. That's a beast of a man.
Pick Grade: B
7a. (228) Chris Chamberlain, CB, Tulsa - Developmental cornerback type. Wowed a lot of people at his pro day, but again didn't play against the best competition in Conference USA. Needs work, and will contribute on special teams.
Pick Grade: C
7b. (252) David Vobora, LB, Idaho - YES! Mr. Irrelevant! I love these guys. That being said this is the best place that a linebacker could go with the final pick. They are pretty much devoid of talent at the position. Vobora is a longshot to make the team.
Pick Grade: C+
Overall Grade: C
I found myself writing "needs development" a whole lot. Do the Rams have the time to be developing talent? Nope. They need help now. That's why I can't give them a better grade. Outside of Long, I don't know how much these guys will help right now.
Pick Grade: A
2. (33) Donnie Avery, WR, Houston - Whoa. Az Hakim alert. This guy was the first receiver taken and really is nothing but a track star. He played in a system that really allowed him to showcase his talent, but that's not saying alot when your playing in conference USA. A HUGE REACH.
Pick Grade: F
3. (65) John Greco, OT, Toledo - I like players from the MAC. Greco is a nasty player who has all of the physical tools to do the job. The thing I like most is the attitude.
Pick Grade: B
4a. (101) Justin King, CB, Penn State - King is a fun case study. He's a big school guy, and he's fast as all hell. However, can he really cover? Let's see. He's probably play nickelback on the fast turf in the Ed Jones dome.
Pick Grade: C
4b. (128) Kennan Burton, WR, Kentucky - This is the developmental receiver pick. Burton is 6'1 and has good speed, but is raw. He was Andre Woodson's top guy at Kentucky, but needs some time to figure out the NFL game.
Pick Grade: C+
5. (157) Roy Schuening, G, Oregon St. - More nasty guards. I like the idea of taking guys who are tough over anything else, and Schuening played the entire year with Pneumonia. That's a beast of a man.
Pick Grade: B
7a. (228) Chris Chamberlain, CB, Tulsa - Developmental cornerback type. Wowed a lot of people at his pro day, but again didn't play against the best competition in Conference USA. Needs work, and will contribute on special teams.
Pick Grade: C
7b. (252) David Vobora, LB, Idaho - YES! Mr. Irrelevant! I love these guys. That being said this is the best place that a linebacker could go with the final pick. They are pretty much devoid of talent at the position. Vobora is a longshot to make the team.
Pick Grade: C+
Overall Grade: C
I found myself writing "needs development" a whole lot. Do the Rams have the time to be developing talent? Nope. They need help now. That's why I can't give them a better grade. Outside of Long, I don't know how much these guys will help right now.
5/14/08
Draft Grades - AFC West - Denver Broncos
1. (12)Ryan Clady, OT, Boise State - Clady is an athletic lineman who fits perfectly in Denvers zone blocking scheme. Clady, in my opinion, was the best left tackle prospect in this draft. And while he is raw and played against a sup-par level of competition at Boise State he has found a home in a perfect scheme and should be a cornerstone for Denver.
Pick Grade - A
2.(42) Eddie Royal, WR, Virginia Tech - I don't love this pick. I understand the Broncos need to add depth to their WR corp. Brandon Marshall, while dominant, has a decorated off field history and as this off season showed us you never know what the hell will happen. Stokley, much like Wes Welker, is a guy who you will use exclusively out of the slot.
Royal is an undersized WR who wasn't productive in college. He also has had trouble staying healthy. Where he excels is after the catch with his breakaway speed and on special teams with his great potential as a return man.
With players like De Sean Jackson, Limas Sweed and Malcom Kelly on the board I question the value you get by selecting Royal here.
Pick Grade - C-
4.(108) - Kory Lichtensteiger, C, Bowling Green - Another reason I like the Zone Blocking Scheme, guys like Kory Lichtensteiger. Productive in college but undervalued because of his size, which isn't ideal in a standard blocking system. Since the Zone Blocking Scheme emphasizes quickness and mobility Kory is a great fit. He might never be a star but he profiles as a starter. He'll be a valuable backup at Guard and Center at worst.
Pick Grade - B+
4. (119) Jack Williams, CB, Kent State - Outstanding Athlete and an underrated prospect. However his size will limit his upside as a pro. He's a prototypical dime/nickel back. While his value is questionable (due to his long-term limitations) this draft was incredibly thin in the secondary and besides taking someone like Jack Ike from Wisconsin this was the best they could do.
Pick Grade - C+
5a. (139) Ryan Torain, RB, Arizona St - Who am I to question a RB that Denver drafts. He was very productive in 2006 but got hurt in 07 and only played in 6 games. I don't love Torain but with Denver's success in finding backs who fit the scheme it's hard not to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Pick Grade - B
5b, (148) Carlton Powell, DT, Virginia Tech - Started at a big college program. Doesn't have a lot of upside but plays the run and pass well and profiles as a solid backup. This late in the draft it's hard to criticize picks but I would have preferred to roll the dice with someone like Frank Okam instead. Also they have yet to address their needs at DE/LB and Johnathan Goff would have been a nice fit.
Pick Grade: C-
6.(183) - Spencer Larsen, LB, Arizona - Another Eh pick. He has good size and toughness but he's 25 and therefore his upside is insanely limited.
Pick Grade: C+
7a. (220) Josh Barrett, S, Arizona St - A pick I like a lot. Barett has all the physical tools and athleticism. Had a terrible senior year and was benched. However Scouts Inc. believes he could have been a 3rd rounder if he had come out last year and was one of the top safety prospects coming into this year. Had a sick combine and in the 7th round grabbing a guy with his tools is a steal.
Pick Grade: A
7b.(227) Peyton Hillis, FB, Arkansas - I love this pick also. He's a tough player with great versatility. Again, in the 7th round getting someone so productive and versatile is a steal.
Pick Grade: A
Pick Grade - A
2.(42) Eddie Royal, WR, Virginia Tech - I don't love this pick. I understand the Broncos need to add depth to their WR corp. Brandon Marshall, while dominant, has a decorated off field history and as this off season showed us you never know what the hell will happen. Stokley, much like Wes Welker, is a guy who you will use exclusively out of the slot.
Royal is an undersized WR who wasn't productive in college. He also has had trouble staying healthy. Where he excels is after the catch with his breakaway speed and on special teams with his great potential as a return man.
With players like De Sean Jackson, Limas Sweed and Malcom Kelly on the board I question the value you get by selecting Royal here.
Pick Grade - C-
4.(108) - Kory Lichtensteiger, C, Bowling Green - Another reason I like the Zone Blocking Scheme, guys like Kory Lichtensteiger. Productive in college but undervalued because of his size, which isn't ideal in a standard blocking system. Since the Zone Blocking Scheme emphasizes quickness and mobility Kory is a great fit. He might never be a star but he profiles as a starter. He'll be a valuable backup at Guard and Center at worst.
Pick Grade - B+
4. (119) Jack Williams, CB, Kent State - Outstanding Athlete and an underrated prospect. However his size will limit his upside as a pro. He's a prototypical dime/nickel back. While his value is questionable (due to his long-term limitations) this draft was incredibly thin in the secondary and besides taking someone like Jack Ike from Wisconsin this was the best they could do.
Pick Grade - C+
5a. (139) Ryan Torain, RB, Arizona St - Who am I to question a RB that Denver drafts. He was very productive in 2006 but got hurt in 07 and only played in 6 games. I don't love Torain but with Denver's success in finding backs who fit the scheme it's hard not to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Pick Grade - B
5b, (148) Carlton Powell, DT, Virginia Tech - Started at a big college program. Doesn't have a lot of upside but plays the run and pass well and profiles as a solid backup. This late in the draft it's hard to criticize picks but I would have preferred to roll the dice with someone like Frank Okam instead. Also they have yet to address their needs at DE/LB and Johnathan Goff would have been a nice fit.
Pick Grade: C-
6.(183) - Spencer Larsen, LB, Arizona - Another Eh pick. He has good size and toughness but he's 25 and therefore his upside is insanely limited.
Pick Grade: C+
7a. (220) Josh Barrett, S, Arizona St - A pick I like a lot. Barett has all the physical tools and athleticism. Had a terrible senior year and was benched. However Scouts Inc. believes he could have been a 3rd rounder if he had come out last year and was one of the top safety prospects coming into this year. Had a sick combine and in the 7th round grabbing a guy with his tools is a steal.
Pick Grade: A
7b.(227) Peyton Hillis, FB, Arkansas - I love this pick also. He's a tough player with great versatility. Again, in the 7th round getting someone so productive and versatile is a steal.
Pick Grade: A
I find myself torn giving the Broncos an overall grade. I loved the Clady, Lichtensteiger, Barrett and Hillis picks, the rest of the draft I was lukewarm on.
Besides offensive line they didn’t address, mainly DE and LB and I’m not very high on Eddie Royal at WR.
What you can’t complain about is, for a change, the Broncos taking some blue collar guys (Hillis, Larsen, Powell). They have drafted so many troublesome guys with character issues (Marcus Thomas, Mo Clarett and so on.) that totally flopped; it’s a nice change of pace.
Overall Grade: B
5/13/08
Somebody Take Away my Copy of Call of Duty 4...
Before I suffer from general laziness and overexposure to loyal reader Glenn Bedell.
Anyway, We've gotten through two divisions of Draft reviews so far as we head out west. Jason has already begun writing up the Broncos, and I'll begin with the Rams later tonight.
Here's the two Eastern Divisions:
AFC:
New York Jets
New England Patriots
Miami Dolphins
Buffalo Bills
NFC:
Super Bowl Champion New York Giants
Dallas Cowboys
Washington Redskins
Philadelphia Eagles
Anyway, We've gotten through two divisions of Draft reviews so far as we head out west. Jason has already begun writing up the Broncos, and I'll begin with the Rams later tonight.
Here's the two Eastern Divisions:
AFC:
New York Jets
New England Patriots
Miami Dolphins
Buffalo Bills
NFC:
Super Bowl Champion New York Giants
Dallas Cowboys
Washington Redskins
Philadelphia Eagles
5/12/08
NFL Draft Reviews - NFC East - Philadelphia Eagles
2a.(47) - Trevor Laws, DT, Notre Dame - Boo. I don't get this at all. I understand that they have been trying to solidify the interior of that line forever now, but I just don't understand how they are going to do that with Laws. He was a workout warrior, and has a good motor, but that can only do so much to mask a lack of talent.
Pick Grade: D
2b. (49) - DeSean Jackson, WR, California - Jackson is a huge threat in Philly Offense because it's a perfect fit for him. He'll get the ball quickly and he'll have the chance to run in some open space. On kickoff returns is where he'll be at his best, as he was consistently one of the best in nation in college. This was a good player at a great value in the second round.
Completely unrelated note: Did anyone else see the suit that Jackson was wearing on draft day? I wish i could find a picture of it but I can't. Seriously, the suit was horrible, but Jackson made it look damn good. Now, I want a cream colored three piece of my own.
Pick Grade: A
Suit Grade: A++
3. (80) Bryan Smith, OLB, McNeese State - All of these small school guys, it was truly incredible. He's really undersized to play end, which is where alot of people think he will end up. At best case, he'll be another Trent Cole, at worst case, he'll be out of the league quickly.
Pick Grade: C-
4a. (109) Mike McGlynn, OG, Pittsburgh - He was a tackle in college but really opened people's eyes while playing guard at the senior bowl. He's tough, but He'll struggle in pass protection.
Pick Grade: C
4b. (131) Jack Ikegwuonu, CB, Wisconsin - Great Name, better pick. Jack was a top prospect until he hurt his knee and needed to have surgery. He has also had some off-field problems, but in the fourth round is where players with flaws make their cash. Jack has some serious potential.
Pick Grade: A
6a. (184) Mike Gibson, OT, California - See McGlynn, Mike. Same guy.
Pick Grade: C-
6b. (200) Joe Mays, ILB, North Dakota State - Will be a quick developing special teams stud, but at 5'11 there are questions about his ability to be a middle linebacker in this league. Small School competition didn't help his stock.
Pick Grade: C
6c. (203) Andy Studebaker, OLB, Wheaton - Hard to argue against anyone who is named after a classic car, but There are some serious questions about Andy too. He's another guy who projects to a rush end position, but is very undersized. Again, I have to wonder about the lack of top competition.
7. (230) King Dunlop, OT, Auburn - 6'9, 310. That's it. That's all you have to say in the seventh round. Get someone you think you can develop. The King is a steal here.
Pick Grade: B
Total Grade: C+
I didn't get alot of this. They seemed to be picking the best available player, but do they have that luxury? I'm not really sure. I'm thinking that the reality of the whole thing might be that they are still trying to fill certain round holes (DE, LB, DT) with square pegs. I wouldn't expect too much of this class to have huge impacts.
Pick Grade: D
2b. (49) - DeSean Jackson, WR, California - Jackson is a huge threat in Philly Offense because it's a perfect fit for him. He'll get the ball quickly and he'll have the chance to run in some open space. On kickoff returns is where he'll be at his best, as he was consistently one of the best in nation in college. This was a good player at a great value in the second round.
Completely unrelated note: Did anyone else see the suit that Jackson was wearing on draft day? I wish i could find a picture of it but I can't. Seriously, the suit was horrible, but Jackson made it look damn good. Now, I want a cream colored three piece of my own.
Pick Grade: A
Suit Grade: A++
3. (80) Bryan Smith, OLB, McNeese State - All of these small school guys, it was truly incredible. He's really undersized to play end, which is where alot of people think he will end up. At best case, he'll be another Trent Cole, at worst case, he'll be out of the league quickly.
Pick Grade: C-
4a. (109) Mike McGlynn, OG, Pittsburgh - He was a tackle in college but really opened people's eyes while playing guard at the senior bowl. He's tough, but He'll struggle in pass protection.
Pick Grade: C
4b. (131) Jack Ikegwuonu, CB, Wisconsin - Great Name, better pick. Jack was a top prospect until he hurt his knee and needed to have surgery. He has also had some off-field problems, but in the fourth round is where players with flaws make their cash. Jack has some serious potential.
Pick Grade: A
6a. (184) Mike Gibson, OT, California - See McGlynn, Mike. Same guy.
Pick Grade: C-
6b. (200) Joe Mays, ILB, North Dakota State - Will be a quick developing special teams stud, but at 5'11 there are questions about his ability to be a middle linebacker in this league. Small School competition didn't help his stock.
Pick Grade: C
6c. (203) Andy Studebaker, OLB, Wheaton - Hard to argue against anyone who is named after a classic car, but There are some serious questions about Andy too. He's another guy who projects to a rush end position, but is very undersized. Again, I have to wonder about the lack of top competition.
7. (230) King Dunlop, OT, Auburn - 6'9, 310. That's it. That's all you have to say in the seventh round. Get someone you think you can develop. The King is a steal here.
Pick Grade: B
Total Grade: C+
I didn't get alot of this. They seemed to be picking the best available player, but do they have that luxury? I'm not really sure. I'm thinking that the reality of the whole thing might be that they are still trying to fill certain round holes (DE, LB, DT) with square pegs. I wouldn't expect too much of this class to have huge impacts.
5/7/08
AFC East Draft Grades!
The first division is done! Starting with the AFC West tomorrow. In case you missed any of them here's the recap of the AFC East draft grades.
AFC East
Buffalo Bills: B-
New York Jets: C+
Miami Dolphins: B+
New England Patriots: C-
AFC East
Buffalo Bills: B-
New York Jets: C+
Miami Dolphins: B+
New England Patriots: C-
Draft Review AFC East - New England Patriots
Saving the best for last it's time to finish up the AFC East and review the New England Patriots draft.
For years it's seemed the Patriots have needed to overhaul their LB corp and secondary yet they refuse to draft those positions early.
Would they continue that trend this year?
Round 1, Pick 10 (10) (From Saints) Jerod Mayo OLB 6'1" 242 Tennessee
And the Patriots have finally injected some youth at LB! I really like this fit. Mayo is a versatile player (ILB/OLB) with great size and intangibles. He fits like a glove in the 3-4 and will make an immediate impact on defense. Plus the Pat's moved down three spots and picked up a 3rd round pick to boot. A
Round 2, Pick 31 (62) Terrence Wheatley CB 5'9" 178 Colorado
This draft was very thin on corners and really after Talib I don't know how many of these corners have starting potential. Wheatley is a solid player who plays big than his size and is physical. He has a good work ethic and is a Patriots type guy. However, he's small and that will hold him back at the next level. Jason Webster and Ellis Hobbs also are both 5'9". I don't know how the Patriots intend to guard big WR's this year. I think there were a lot more intriguing corners available at this spot (Smith, Molden, Godfrey) who they could afford to roll the dice with. D
Round 3, Pick 15 (78) (From Saints) Shawn Crable OLB 6'5" 241 Michigan
Another player who fits great. Crable is a big, smart experienced LB from a big college program. Much like Mayo he can play inside or outside. He is another guy who will make an immediate impact on the Pats D and become a standout on special teams. B+
Round 3, Pick 31 (94) Kevin O'Connell QB 6'5" 225 San Diego State
From the people who brought you Tom Brady bring you Kevin O'Connell! I mean he has the experience (4 year starter plus red shirt year) and the size. He has decent speed and can make some things happen with his feet. However he's a project and a big one at that. I understand the need for a long term back up behind Brady but, when you see how late some like Woodson lasted you can only assume this pick was a big big reach. I also would have preferred Woodson to O'Connell as the toolsy project QB. D
Round 4, Pick 30 (129) Jonathan Wilhite CB 5'10" 185 Auburn
I like Wilhite. Three year starter in the SEC and is a little underrated. I don't know if he ever projects a starter but as a nickel or dime guy he could find a role. B
Round 5, Pick 18 (153) (From Buccaneers) Matt Slater WR 5'11" 195 UCLA
I mean this is a pick just for special teams (maybe gimmick plays) but there were WR's left who could have been taken for special teams purposes and fill a role catching passes. This pick is a giant reach. F
Round 6, Pick 31 (197) Bo Ruud OLB 6'4" 234 Nebraska
The younger brother of current Bucs middle linebacker Barrett Ruud. Might be able to make the team as a special teams standout but really he was more of an undrafted free agent type than a 6th rounder. C-
This was a weird draft for the Patriots. It's hard to make an overall draft grade for them for a few reasons. One, they hit on a lot of players who will make an immediate impact. Two, they also acquired a second round pick next year for a third rounder this year which was a shrewd move and has to boost their grade slightly. Three, Kevin O'Connell is a total wild card. Fourth, their the Patriots...there going to be good and it seems no matter who they throw out their in the secondary they will succeeded.
Finally the reason this is a weird draft is spy gate. Not going to beat a dead horse but the Pat's lost a first round pick (and likely a very talented player) because they cheated. I think you have to knock their grade down because of this.
C-
For years it's seemed the Patriots have needed to overhaul their LB corp and secondary yet they refuse to draft those positions early.
Would they continue that trend this year?
Round 1, Pick 10 (10) (From Saints) Jerod Mayo OLB 6'1" 242 Tennessee
And the Patriots have finally injected some youth at LB! I really like this fit. Mayo is a versatile player (ILB/OLB) with great size and intangibles. He fits like a glove in the 3-4 and will make an immediate impact on defense. Plus the Pat's moved down three spots and picked up a 3rd round pick to boot. A
Round 2, Pick 31 (62) Terrence Wheatley CB 5'9" 178 Colorado
This draft was very thin on corners and really after Talib I don't know how many of these corners have starting potential. Wheatley is a solid player who plays big than his size and is physical. He has a good work ethic and is a Patriots type guy. However, he's small and that will hold him back at the next level. Jason Webster and Ellis Hobbs also are both 5'9". I don't know how the Patriots intend to guard big WR's this year. I think there were a lot more intriguing corners available at this spot (Smith, Molden, Godfrey) who they could afford to roll the dice with. D
Round 3, Pick 15 (78) (From Saints) Shawn Crable OLB 6'5" 241 Michigan
Another player who fits great. Crable is a big, smart experienced LB from a big college program. Much like Mayo he can play inside or outside. He is another guy who will make an immediate impact on the Pats D and become a standout on special teams. B+
Round 3, Pick 31 (94) Kevin O'Connell QB 6'5" 225 San Diego State
From the people who brought you Tom Brady bring you Kevin O'Connell! I mean he has the experience (4 year starter plus red shirt year) and the size. He has decent speed and can make some things happen with his feet. However he's a project and a big one at that. I understand the need for a long term back up behind Brady but, when you see how late some like Woodson lasted you can only assume this pick was a big big reach. I also would have preferred Woodson to O'Connell as the toolsy project QB. D
Round 4, Pick 30 (129) Jonathan Wilhite CB 5'10" 185 Auburn
I like Wilhite. Three year starter in the SEC and is a little underrated. I don't know if he ever projects a starter but as a nickel or dime guy he could find a role. B
Round 5, Pick 18 (153) (From Buccaneers) Matt Slater WR 5'11" 195 UCLA
I mean this is a pick just for special teams (maybe gimmick plays) but there were WR's left who could have been taken for special teams purposes and fill a role catching passes. This pick is a giant reach. F
Round 6, Pick 31 (197) Bo Ruud OLB 6'4" 234 Nebraska
The younger brother of current Bucs middle linebacker Barrett Ruud. Might be able to make the team as a special teams standout but really he was more of an undrafted free agent type than a 6th rounder. C-
This was a weird draft for the Patriots. It's hard to make an overall draft grade for them for a few reasons. One, they hit on a lot of players who will make an immediate impact. Two, they also acquired a second round pick next year for a third rounder this year which was a shrewd move and has to boost their grade slightly. Three, Kevin O'Connell is a total wild card. Fourth, their the Patriots...there going to be good and it seems no matter who they throw out their in the secondary they will succeeded.
Finally the reason this is a weird draft is spy gate. Not going to beat a dead horse but the Pat's lost a first round pick (and likely a very talented player) because they cheated. I think you have to knock their grade down because of this.
C-
5/3/08
Draft Grades - AFC East New York Jets
The Jets are on the clock are the most exciting words you can hear on the draft day. The Jet's have had had an infamous amount of draft blunders but recently they have excelled on daft day. The Jets haven't shied away from trading picks/players and this year was no different.
Round 1, Pick 6 (6) Vernon Gholston DE 6'4" 258 Ohio State
Todd McShay you are wrong. McShay has been the number one critic of Gholston and I can't disagree more. As Anthony put it bluntly "How can you disappear on film if you have an insanely productive college career" He has more sacks than any Division I player over last two seasons (23). Of course there's a risk that he might be a bust...but you run that risk with any player. He is a bit of a workout warrior and you don't know how he'll project playing 3-4 OLB but he certainly will bring a fierce pass rush with him to New York. I still would have preferred the Jets to trade down and address other needs (WR/CB) but at this spot Gholston represented the best value and fit a need. A-
Watch out NFL there's another NY linebacker with the #56 on the prowl.
Round 1, Pick 30 (30) (From Packers) Dustin Keller TE 6'3" 242 Purdue
Let's start with the good. Keller a converted WR will give the Jet's another option in the passing game. At best he can be Dalls Clark, whos a tight end in name only. A tight end with great speed and hands can be a QB's best friend and a great saftey valve in the passing game. Also, to move back up into the first round the Jet's didn't have to surrender a ton of picks. (their 2nd and 4th)
However, I'm left scratching my head a bit. I just don't know if Keller helps the Jets as much as someone like Devin Thomas or Limas Sweed would have. They Jets still don't have many game breaking types on offense and Thomas would have fit the bill. Keller also doesn't have great height for a TE (6'2) and Sweed would have provided the big target the Jets lack. Also what about Chris Baker? He was underused in the Jets offense, to make this pick worthwhile Keller must be targeted often in the passing game. C
Round 4, Pick 14 (113) (From Saints through Packers) Dwight Lowery CB 6'1" 185 San Jose State
Good special teams player. More of a zone cover than a man to man cover and in that regard I don't see him as a great fit for the Jets. I think he fits better as a play making FS and in that role he could be great. I think this pick was a bit of a reach and in general one thing I hated about the Jets draft was that they didn't pick up a Corner or Wide Receiver earlier. Who's starting alongside Reveis? D
Round 5, Pick 27 (162) (From Packers) Erik Ainge QB 6'6" 225 Tennessee
Like the Pick and I'm surprised he lasted this long. Ainge has great tools and I belive he can be a starting QB in this league. The Jets needed a long term backup anyway because Chad isn't going to be wearing Green and White for much longer. The only knock about this pick is that I feel that Andre Woodson has much more upside. B+
Round 6, Pick 5 (171) Marcus Henry WR 6'4" 207 Kansas
Big wide out with great size. Has a great work ethic. A one year wonder and his upside is questionable. At least he's a big body who can contribute on special teams. C
Round 7, Pick 4 (211) Nate Garner OT 6'6" 334 Arkansas
A depth pick. Team is shallow on the O-Line so he should be able to make the club. Big strong guy. C+
Also factoring into this draft is Kris Jenkins, the Jets new nose tackle. We've talked about Jenkins a ton so I'm not going to beat a dead horse. Jenkins has a ton of upside and a (literal) ton of risk.
What bothered me about this Jets draft (and off season in general) was they seem to be putting all their eggs in one basket. They didn't have a lot of draft selections because of trades (Jenkins and Keller) and didn't address obvious needs in the draft (CB/WR/FS.)
This is a shallow team and if all the new personnel doesn't gel or their young QB doesn't develop this team is going to be a mess.
C+
Round 1, Pick 6 (6) Vernon Gholston DE 6'4" 258 Ohio State
Todd McShay you are wrong. McShay has been the number one critic of Gholston and I can't disagree more. As Anthony put it bluntly "How can you disappear on film if you have an insanely productive college career" He has more sacks than any Division I player over last two seasons (23). Of course there's a risk that he might be a bust...but you run that risk with any player. He is a bit of a workout warrior and you don't know how he'll project playing 3-4 OLB but he certainly will bring a fierce pass rush with him to New York. I still would have preferred the Jets to trade down and address other needs (WR/CB) but at this spot Gholston represented the best value and fit a need. A-
Watch out NFL there's another NY linebacker with the #56 on the prowl.
Round 1, Pick 30 (30) (From Packers) Dustin Keller TE 6'3" 242 Purdue
Let's start with the good. Keller a converted WR will give the Jet's another option in the passing game. At best he can be Dalls Clark, whos a tight end in name only. A tight end with great speed and hands can be a QB's best friend and a great saftey valve in the passing game. Also, to move back up into the first round the Jet's didn't have to surrender a ton of picks. (their 2nd and 4th)
However, I'm left scratching my head a bit. I just don't know if Keller helps the Jets as much as someone like Devin Thomas or Limas Sweed would have. They Jets still don't have many game breaking types on offense and Thomas would have fit the bill. Keller also doesn't have great height for a TE (6'2) and Sweed would have provided the big target the Jets lack. Also what about Chris Baker? He was underused in the Jets offense, to make this pick worthwhile Keller must be targeted often in the passing game. C
Round 4, Pick 14 (113) (From Saints through Packers) Dwight Lowery CB 6'1" 185 San Jose State
Good special teams player. More of a zone cover than a man to man cover and in that regard I don't see him as a great fit for the Jets. I think he fits better as a play making FS and in that role he could be great. I think this pick was a bit of a reach and in general one thing I hated about the Jets draft was that they didn't pick up a Corner or Wide Receiver earlier. Who's starting alongside Reveis? D
Round 5, Pick 27 (162) (From Packers) Erik Ainge QB 6'6" 225 Tennessee
Like the Pick and I'm surprised he lasted this long. Ainge has great tools and I belive he can be a starting QB in this league. The Jets needed a long term backup anyway because Chad isn't going to be wearing Green and White for much longer. The only knock about this pick is that I feel that Andre Woodson has much more upside. B+
Round 6, Pick 5 (171) Marcus Henry WR 6'4" 207 Kansas
Big wide out with great size. Has a great work ethic. A one year wonder and his upside is questionable. At least he's a big body who can contribute on special teams. C
Round 7, Pick 4 (211) Nate Garner OT 6'6" 334 Arkansas
A depth pick. Team is shallow on the O-Line so he should be able to make the club. Big strong guy. C+
Also factoring into this draft is Kris Jenkins, the Jets new nose tackle. We've talked about Jenkins a ton so I'm not going to beat a dead horse. Jenkins has a ton of upside and a (literal) ton of risk.
What bothered me about this Jets draft (and off season in general) was they seem to be putting all their eggs in one basket. They didn't have a lot of draft selections because of trades (Jenkins and Keller) and didn't address obvious needs in the draft (CB/WR/FS.)
This is a shallow team and if all the new personnel doesn't gel or their young QB doesn't develop this team is going to be a mess.
C+
5/2/08
Draft Grades - NFC East - Dallas Cowboys!
1a.(22) Felix Jones, RB, Arkansas - Wow, who didn't see this coming? Jones is from Arkansas, as is Jerry Jones, and what do we all know about Jerry? Huge ego. Anyway, it does make sense as a football decision, as Jones' excellent hands and is explosive enough to be a good changeup to MBIII. However, what happens when Barber wants more money? How much can you two runners? Trouble may be brewing in Big D.
Pick Grade: B+
1b. (25) Mike Jenkins, CB, South Florida - I've beleived all along that Jenkins and McKelvin should have been mentioned alongside one another as the top two corners in this draft. He has all the physical tools necessary, but now the question is can he put it all together and become a top flight NFL corner? Stay Tuned.
Pick Grade: A-
2. (61) Martellus Bennett, TE, Texas A&M - Don't look for Bennett to become too much of a factor in the passing game. He has good size and will block well, but his technique, and speed will never allow him to be a receiver.
Pick Grade: C
4. (122) Tashard Choice, RB, Georgia Tech - It's a shame Choice will be relagated to kickoff returns, because he is a good runner. He came into the year as a top back, but struggled at times this season. The funny things about RB's is that sometimes all they need is a chance to play. I think that Choice needs that chance.
Pick Grade: B
5. (143) Orlando Scandrick, CB, Boise State - MAJOR character concerns means sign Jerry Jones up. He loves these guys. Before he ever takes the field, he's got to get his act straight quick. On the field, he's got nickel corner written all over him.
Pick Grade: D
6. (167) Erik Walden, DE/OLB, Middle Tennessee St. - Reeks of 3-4 OLB, and had 22.5 sacks in college. Sounds like a late round flyer to me.
Pick Grade: B-
Total Grade: B
Scandrick and Bennett keep this haul from being really great. Jones and Jenkins will contribute now, but I question how long Jones and Barber will work together. That said, this is why the NFC East is so good, Three of the four teams always draft well, and now the Redskins have joined the party.
Pick Grade: B+
1b. (25) Mike Jenkins, CB, South Florida - I've beleived all along that Jenkins and McKelvin should have been mentioned alongside one another as the top two corners in this draft. He has all the physical tools necessary, but now the question is can he put it all together and become a top flight NFL corner? Stay Tuned.
Pick Grade: A-
2. (61) Martellus Bennett, TE, Texas A&M - Don't look for Bennett to become too much of a factor in the passing game. He has good size and will block well, but his technique, and speed will never allow him to be a receiver.
Pick Grade: C
4. (122) Tashard Choice, RB, Georgia Tech - It's a shame Choice will be relagated to kickoff returns, because he is a good runner. He came into the year as a top back, but struggled at times this season. The funny things about RB's is that sometimes all they need is a chance to play. I think that Choice needs that chance.
Pick Grade: B
5. (143) Orlando Scandrick, CB, Boise State - MAJOR character concerns means sign Jerry Jones up. He loves these guys. Before he ever takes the field, he's got to get his act straight quick. On the field, he's got nickel corner written all over him.
Pick Grade: D
6. (167) Erik Walden, DE/OLB, Middle Tennessee St. - Reeks of 3-4 OLB, and had 22.5 sacks in college. Sounds like a late round flyer to me.
Pick Grade: B-
Total Grade: B
Scandrick and Bennett keep this haul from being really great. Jones and Jenkins will contribute now, but I question how long Jones and Barber will work together. That said, this is why the NFC East is so good, Three of the four teams always draft well, and now the Redskins have joined the party.
4/29/08
Draft Grades: AFC East - Miami Dolphins!
Armed with many early draft picks and a rebuilding blue print (from the Big Tuna himself) the Dolphins were one of three teams (the others being K.C and ATL) who really had a chance to remake their team in one fell swoop.
Were they successful? Yes and no.
1 1(1) Jake Long OT MICHIGAN
I've always questioned Long's ability to play left tackle. To me the jury is still out till he proves he can do it. However the fact that Parcells, Ireland and Sparano (an offensive line coach) gave Long their blessing certainly is an indication of his ability. On the positive side, I always say that continuity is the most important part of an offensive line (See; Kendall, Pete) and with Long at LT, Carey slides over to a more natural RT position (instantly making him better.) When you add in Smiley and Setale they all of a sudden could have one of the best young offensive lines in football. B
2 1(32) Phillip Merling DE CLEMSON
Merling had fallen cause of a sports hernia but he was said to have had a very solid pro day just mere days before the draft. He was a mid first round talent before his injury so you can't argue with the value at the top of round two. He's going to be a 5 technique 3-4 end in Parcells defense and should excel at it. B+
2 26(57) Chad Henne QB MICHIGAN
You know Jon Beck's going be 27 years old this season? I mean, Wow. How could he even be expected to be a "franchise" QB. We all know how I feel about Henne. I love him, he's going to need work...but any young QB does. With all due respect to Joe Flacco I'd rather my toolsy QB with his share of issues come from a big program with big game experience. Love the fit and love the value. A
3 3(66) Kendall Langford DE HAMPTON
Continuing the building in the trenches theme. Parcells really knows what he's doing, and I'm trying not to just sound like a Parcells homer, but building inside out is the way to go. Langford is not a sexy pick by any means. But he's going to be another 5 technique run stopping end. In fact his body is more naturally suited to it than Merling possibly. B+
4 11(110) Shawn Murphy OG UTAH STATE
Murphy is a small-school prospect with good quickness and size. However he is going to be a project. I like the fit pairing a raw offensive line prospect with an offensive line minded coach but I question the value. On the baord still at this point were Anthony Collins, Lavelle Hawkins and Red Bryant all who fit needs for the Fins and presented better values. C-
6 10(176) Jalen Parmele RB TOLEDO
Interesting player. Could be a workout warrior but had two very productive years at Toledo. I know it's the late rounds so it's hard to nitpick but the Dolphins totally neglected other needs with this pick. At RB they had Brown, Cobbs and Williams. D+
6 29(195) Donald Thomas OG CONNECTICUT
Another developmental lineman. Scott Wright likes his upside and had him as a mid rounder. He was arrested in 2006 for assault which would go against Parcells's no bad apples theory. B-
6 38(204) Lex Hilliard RB MONTANA
Another RB? Once again, I know 6th round but no CB or WR taken at all this draft? Hillard's only significant impact would come as a versatile fullback D+
7 38(245) Lionel Dotson DT ARIZONA
If he makes an NFL Team it'd be with a 3-4 team. However he has more of an end body than a NT body and the Fins drafted now three of the same type of player. D
My biggest problem I had with the Dolphins draft is the fact that they didn't trade Jason Taylor. Look if you only get a late second or a third for him it's ok. When this team is going to be good enough to compete for a championship he still be playing for them. They didn't address needs at CB or WR and trading Taylor could have helped that. Wouldn't the addition of Reggie Smith or Charles Godfey really make this draft a ridiculous haul?
In the end I don't have a lot to gripe about. I liked most of Parcells picks and when you factor in that they basically stole Anthony Fasano and Aykin Adoyle from Dallas for a 4th rounder it's a very nice draft for a rebuilding team.
Final Draft Grade: B+
Were they successful? Yes and no.
1 1(1) Jake Long OT MICHIGAN
I've always questioned Long's ability to play left tackle. To me the jury is still out till he proves he can do it. However the fact that Parcells, Ireland and Sparano (an offensive line coach) gave Long their blessing certainly is an indication of his ability. On the positive side, I always say that continuity is the most important part of an offensive line (See; Kendall, Pete) and with Long at LT, Carey slides over to a more natural RT position (instantly making him better.) When you add in Smiley and Setale they all of a sudden could have one of the best young offensive lines in football. B
2 1(32) Phillip Merling DE CLEMSON
Merling had fallen cause of a sports hernia but he was said to have had a very solid pro day just mere days before the draft. He was a mid first round talent before his injury so you can't argue with the value at the top of round two. He's going to be a 5 technique 3-4 end in Parcells defense and should excel at it. B+
2 26(57) Chad Henne QB MICHIGAN
You know Jon Beck's going be 27 years old this season? I mean, Wow. How could he even be expected to be a "franchise" QB. We all know how I feel about Henne. I love him, he's going to need work...but any young QB does. With all due respect to Joe Flacco I'd rather my toolsy QB with his share of issues come from a big program with big game experience. Love the fit and love the value. A
3 3(66) Kendall Langford DE HAMPTON
Continuing the building in the trenches theme. Parcells really knows what he's doing, and I'm trying not to just sound like a Parcells homer, but building inside out is the way to go. Langford is not a sexy pick by any means. But he's going to be another 5 technique run stopping end. In fact his body is more naturally suited to it than Merling possibly. B+
4 11(110) Shawn Murphy OG UTAH STATE
Murphy is a small-school prospect with good quickness and size. However he is going to be a project. I like the fit pairing a raw offensive line prospect with an offensive line minded coach but I question the value. On the baord still at this point were Anthony Collins, Lavelle Hawkins and Red Bryant all who fit needs for the Fins and presented better values. C-
6 10(176) Jalen Parmele RB TOLEDO
Interesting player. Could be a workout warrior but had two very productive years at Toledo. I know it's the late rounds so it's hard to nitpick but the Dolphins totally neglected other needs with this pick. At RB they had Brown, Cobbs and Williams. D+
6 29(195) Donald Thomas OG CONNECTICUT
Another developmental lineman. Scott Wright likes his upside and had him as a mid rounder. He was arrested in 2006 for assault which would go against Parcells's no bad apples theory. B-
6 38(204) Lex Hilliard RB MONTANA
Another RB? Once again, I know 6th round but no CB or WR taken at all this draft? Hillard's only significant impact would come as a versatile fullback D+
7 38(245) Lionel Dotson DT ARIZONA
If he makes an NFL Team it'd be with a 3-4 team. However he has more of an end body than a NT body and the Fins drafted now three of the same type of player. D
My biggest problem I had with the Dolphins draft is the fact that they didn't trade Jason Taylor. Look if you only get a late second or a third for him it's ok. When this team is going to be good enough to compete for a championship he still be playing for them. They didn't address needs at CB or WR and trading Taylor could have helped that. Wouldn't the addition of Reggie Smith or Charles Godfey really make this draft a ridiculous haul?
In the end I don't have a lot to gripe about. I liked most of Parcells picks and when you factor in that they basically stole Anthony Fasano and Aykin Adoyle from Dallas for a 4th rounder it's a very nice draft for a rebuilding team.
Final Draft Grade: B+
4/28/08
Team-by-Team Draft Review: New York Giants!
1. Kenny Phillips, S, Miami - This is the guy that the Giants wanted all along. That's good, because I think all the fans wanted him to. For those of you who aren't familiar with Phillips, Take Gibril Wilson; his nose for the ball, his reckless abandon, his lack of fear of anyone, and now give him better physical skills. Boom, that's Kenny Phillips. K-Phil is also much better in coverage than Gibril ever was. I'll never hate on Wilson and all he brought to the team, but I'm a lot less sad that he left now than I was Friday.
Pick Grade: A
2. Terrell Thomas, CB, USC - Thomas is an interesting case that proves something about the Giants war room that a lot of people already know: Jerry Reese is all about Size and Speed. Thomas is big at 6'0, 202, and has the strength to jam any receiver at the line. He is instinctive when the ball is in the air. Why was he taken in the 2nd round then? Well, there are two reasons: First, he lacks proper technique right now. He's not that smooth and doesn't always pop his hips open well. The other, more important concern is that he has a history of injuries that is troubling. He's dislocated both shoulders trying to tackle runners in 2003, and 2007 and tore ligaments in his knee in 2005
Pick Grade: B-
3. Mario Manningham, WR, Michigan - This is another Size/Speed guy. However, there is one confusing thing about this. When you watch film of Manningham, you notice two things. The first, negative thing is that you don't see a whole lot of separation from college corners. That's troubling because separation is a good way to tell if a receiver is going to be successful in the NFL. If you can't get open against college corners, how can you get open against Champ Bailey and Dre Bly? You can't.
However, There is something else you notice. He has a Plaxico Burress-like ability to go up and get the ball at the height of it's flight and pull it away from defenders. However, is that enough to be an NFL receiver?
I don't know.
Pick Grade - C
4. Bryan Kehl, OLB, BYU - Kehl has a lot of upside. He's a much better athlete than he is a linebacker, but accepts coaching well, and I'm willing to bet that the team thinks that it can turn him into a starting caliber linebacker. He'll immediately make an impact on special teams and will work of playing lower and hitting the hole on running plays all summer. I like this pick.
Pick Grade - B+
5. Jonathan Goff, ILB, Vanderbilt - He'll move to the outside in the NFL. I'm a little annoyed here, because I really like Wes Woodyard out of Kentucky (famous for Mike Singletary referring to him as "Hey, Kentucky!" all week during Senior Bowl practice.) but seeing as he is small, I doubted Reese would like him as I did. I don't see Goff being anything more than a special teamer.
Pick Grade: C
6. Andre Woodson, QB, Kentucky - I've been talking up Woodson for a long time now based on this theory: He was uber-successful in college with HORRIBLE mechanics. What happens if he ever gets them right? He'd be a monster. That being said, Andre will most likely never play a snap for the Giants, but hey Matt Schaub brought in a second round pick...and in the sixth round, why the hell not?
Pick Grade: B+
6b. Robert Henderson, Southern Mississippi - VERY raw pass rusher. Then, again so was Osi...
Pick Grade: B
Overall Grade: B+
Good Value in the first two rounds, lots of Size-Speed gambles on day two. It's the same formula as last year, and that worked out ok.
Pick Grade: A
2. Terrell Thomas, CB, USC - Thomas is an interesting case that proves something about the Giants war room that a lot of people already know: Jerry Reese is all about Size and Speed. Thomas is big at 6'0, 202, and has the strength to jam any receiver at the line. He is instinctive when the ball is in the air. Why was he taken in the 2nd round then? Well, there are two reasons: First, he lacks proper technique right now. He's not that smooth and doesn't always pop his hips open well. The other, more important concern is that he has a history of injuries that is troubling. He's dislocated both shoulders trying to tackle runners in 2003, and 2007 and tore ligaments in his knee in 2005
Pick Grade: B-
3. Mario Manningham, WR, Michigan - This is another Size/Speed guy. However, there is one confusing thing about this. When you watch film of Manningham, you notice two things. The first, negative thing is that you don't see a whole lot of separation from college corners. That's troubling because separation is a good way to tell if a receiver is going to be successful in the NFL. If you can't get open against college corners, how can you get open against Champ Bailey and Dre Bly? You can't.
However, There is something else you notice. He has a Plaxico Burress-like ability to go up and get the ball at the height of it's flight and pull it away from defenders. However, is that enough to be an NFL receiver?
I don't know.
Pick Grade - C
4. Bryan Kehl, OLB, BYU - Kehl has a lot of upside. He's a much better athlete than he is a linebacker, but accepts coaching well, and I'm willing to bet that the team thinks that it can turn him into a starting caliber linebacker. He'll immediately make an impact on special teams and will work of playing lower and hitting the hole on running plays all summer. I like this pick.
Pick Grade - B+
5. Jonathan Goff, ILB, Vanderbilt - He'll move to the outside in the NFL. I'm a little annoyed here, because I really like Wes Woodyard out of Kentucky (famous for Mike Singletary referring to him as "Hey, Kentucky!" all week during Senior Bowl practice.) but seeing as he is small, I doubted Reese would like him as I did. I don't see Goff being anything more than a special teamer.
Pick Grade: C
6. Andre Woodson, QB, Kentucky - I've been talking up Woodson for a long time now based on this theory: He was uber-successful in college with HORRIBLE mechanics. What happens if he ever gets them right? He'd be a monster. That being said, Andre will most likely never play a snap for the Giants, but hey Matt Schaub brought in a second round pick...and in the sixth round, why the hell not?
Pick Grade: B+
6b. Robert Henderson, Southern Mississippi - VERY raw pass rusher. Then, again so was Osi...
Pick Grade: B
Overall Grade: B+
Good Value in the first two rounds, lots of Size-Speed gambles on day two. It's the same formula as last year, and that worked out ok.
Draft Grades: AFC East - Buffalo Bills
So I've taking some time to digest this draft and you know what...it really wasn't that great of a draft class. There was some value to be had in Rounds 2-5 but other than that I'm completely underwhelmed. As a whole I think every teams draft grade is going to be lower than in years past. If there was ever a year to trade down or trade for future picks this was it.
Before we dig into the grades there has been a lot of discussion about the new format of the draft. My take, I didn't like it. The later started time allowed time for WAYYYYYYYY to many leaks. We shouldn't know the top 4 picks hours before the draft. Where's the excitement if your a Jet fan seeing if McFadden will fall? I don't know how I feel about the shorter time between picks. I think we saw more trades because of the limited time, there was less time for B.S.. I think though with the 10 minutes it almost went too fast at times. Picks happened so quickly at points you couldn't really digest everything. I think the Draft still needs some tweaking I just don't know how.
And now on to the Buffalo Bills Draft Grade.
Everyone and their mother expected the Bills to go WR early. Well what we didn't expect was that NO NFL TEAM had a first round grade on any of the WR's in the draft.
With their first pick (11) the Bills selected CB Leodis McKelvin. He has great speed, size, cover skills and he's also a dangerous return man. With this pick the Bills addressed a big need and got an exceptional value. A-
With their second round pick (41) the Bills addressed their need for a big WR by drafting James Hardy. While Hardy at this spot was a good value and hit their need for a big possession guy to play alongside speedster Lee Evans he comes with many red flags. He was inconsistent in college and doesn't always adjust his body well to the ball. He seems to rely more on his size/athleticism to bring down balls than proper technique. Besides the on field questions, he has a decorated rap sheet of off the field issues. Indiana suspended him for two games for an off-the-field incident in 2006 and character is somewhat of a concern. With Sweed still on the board I have to question their decision to guy with the guy who's a much bigger gamble. B-
3 9(72) Chris Ellis DE VIRGINIA TECH
An undersized pass rushing end. Might have to be relegated to a situational role. He also has character issues. Suspended in 2006 after he was arrested and charged with resisting arrest and obstructing justice. So this is questionable character guy number two. The one thing I like about Ellis is than unlike a lot of other college players he was productive in school. C+
4 15(114) Reggie Corner CB AKRON
Buffalo did need depth at Corner but this pick was a reach. Though Corner has an awesome name he doesn't have top notch measurables. He's small and has trouble with bigger WR's. He projects at best as nickel guy. He might not have the physical stature to make it in the league. I would have rather rolled the dice with a guy who might be able to make an impact but is more boom or a bust than a guy with such a low ceiling. D
4 33(132) Derek Fine TE KANSAS
Small for a tight end. Could carve out a Ben Utech type role but for a run first team a receiving tight end doesn't make sense. Scott Wright had him as the 19th best tight end in the draft. F
5 12(147) Alvin Bowen OLB IOWA STATE
Undersized. However this is the right defense (Cover Two) to give him a chance to succeed. Might not be able to be an every down player and has to contribute on special teams to make the roster. C-
6 13(179) Xavier Omon RB NW MISSOURI ST
Speed is an issue. The team already had several running backs in the fold. Didn't like this pick. If they moved him to fullback I would feel better about this pick. C
7 12(219) Demetrius Bell OT NORTHWESTERN ST
Small school developmental guy who has the tools to start. Can't ask for much else in the 7th round. B+
7 17(224) Steve Johnson WR KENTUCKY
Has a Wes Welker in him. Pretty good value in the 7th round. B+
7 44(251) Kennard Cox CB PITTSBURGH
Needs to produce on special teams to make the roster. C
OVERALL GRADE: B-
I liked McKelvin and Hardy and they both addressed needs. The middle of the draft (Ellis, Corner, Fine) was suspect but they were able to grab some intriguing guys in the 6/7th round.
An overall grade isn't based on an average. Remember the picks have to be weighted accrodingly to round and so on.
Before we dig into the grades there has been a lot of discussion about the new format of the draft. My take, I didn't like it. The later started time allowed time for WAYYYYYYYY to many leaks. We shouldn't know the top 4 picks hours before the draft. Where's the excitement if your a Jet fan seeing if McFadden will fall? I don't know how I feel about the shorter time between picks. I think we saw more trades because of the limited time, there was less time for B.S.. I think though with the 10 minutes it almost went too fast at times. Picks happened so quickly at points you couldn't really digest everything. I think the Draft still needs some tweaking I just don't know how.
And now on to the Buffalo Bills Draft Grade.
Everyone and their mother expected the Bills to go WR early. Well what we didn't expect was that NO NFL TEAM had a first round grade on any of the WR's in the draft.
With their first pick (11) the Bills selected CB Leodis McKelvin. He has great speed, size, cover skills and he's also a dangerous return man. With this pick the Bills addressed a big need and got an exceptional value. A-
With their second round pick (41) the Bills addressed their need for a big WR by drafting James Hardy. While Hardy at this spot was a good value and hit their need for a big possession guy to play alongside speedster Lee Evans he comes with many red flags. He was inconsistent in college and doesn't always adjust his body well to the ball. He seems to rely more on his size/athleticism to bring down balls than proper technique. Besides the on field questions, he has a decorated rap sheet of off the field issues. Indiana suspended him for two games for an off-the-field incident in 2006 and character is somewhat of a concern. With Sweed still on the board I have to question their decision to guy with the guy who's a much bigger gamble. B-
3 9(72) Chris Ellis DE VIRGINIA TECH
An undersized pass rushing end. Might have to be relegated to a situational role. He also has character issues. Suspended in 2006 after he was arrested and charged with resisting arrest and obstructing justice. So this is questionable character guy number two. The one thing I like about Ellis is than unlike a lot of other college players he was productive in school. C+
4 15(114) Reggie Corner CB AKRON
Buffalo did need depth at Corner but this pick was a reach. Though Corner has an awesome name he doesn't have top notch measurables. He's small and has trouble with bigger WR's. He projects at best as nickel guy. He might not have the physical stature to make it in the league. I would have rather rolled the dice with a guy who might be able to make an impact but is more boom or a bust than a guy with such a low ceiling. D
4 33(132) Derek Fine TE KANSAS
Small for a tight end. Could carve out a Ben Utech type role but for a run first team a receiving tight end doesn't make sense. Scott Wright had him as the 19th best tight end in the draft. F
5 12(147) Alvin Bowen OLB IOWA STATE
Undersized. However this is the right defense (Cover Two) to give him a chance to succeed. Might not be able to be an every down player and has to contribute on special teams to make the roster. C-
6 13(179) Xavier Omon RB NW MISSOURI ST
Speed is an issue. The team already had several running backs in the fold. Didn't like this pick. If they moved him to fullback I would feel better about this pick. C
7 12(219) Demetrius Bell OT NORTHWESTERN ST
Small school developmental guy who has the tools to start. Can't ask for much else in the 7th round. B+
7 17(224) Steve Johnson WR KENTUCKY
Has a Wes Welker in him. Pretty good value in the 7th round. B+
7 44(251) Kennard Cox CB PITTSBURGH
Needs to produce on special teams to make the roster. C
OVERALL GRADE: B-
I liked McKelvin and Hardy and they both addressed needs. The middle of the draft (Ellis, Corner, Fine) was suspect but they were able to grab some intriguing guys in the 6/7th round.
An overall grade isn't based on an average. Remember the picks have to be weighted accrodingly to round and so on.